Orbital vs. Radial

What’s the difference?

Posted on 02/20/2019 | by The Orbitform Blog Team

 

We hear it all the time – what is the difference between orbital and radial riveting. It’s an important subject to discuss when designing a new assembly and looking for the right fastening or forming process. To help you better understand each process and find the right solution, we have put together a few comparisons to consider.

 

Forming a tenon

The most obvious difference in orbital and radial riveting is the tool path of the peen. With orbital riveting, the peen is held at a fixed angle, typically 6°, and rotates over the fastener in a circular motion. As it rotates along the tenon, it gently forms the material. The 6° angle uses up to 80% less force than a press and creates approximately a 10% sideload. Radial riveting is quite different. The radial peen tool begins in the center and forms outward in a fleurette design. This process creates less side load but requires more force as it travels directly over the tenon.

Common uses and considerations

Due to the forming force required, radial riveting is most often used with small and delicate parts, such as endoscopic medical tools or inside watch components. As the size of the rivet increases, so too does the forming force, making it harder for radial riveting to be completed on larger diameter rivets due to the tooling path. As the tooling path travels directly over the top of the rivet and approaches 0 °, shank swell is increased due to the increased forming force, which can limit the joint’s ability to articulate. With orbital riveting less forming force is required due to the angle of the peen and tool path. The indirect force applied to the tenon creates less shank swell and can allow for articulating joints. The range of assemblies benefiting from this type of riveting include pinion gears, industrial sprinklers, striker wires, etc. etc.

Maintenance

The largest consideration manufacturers should consider is the long-term cost of maintenance and tooling to be used for each type of forming. The tooling path of radial riveting is quite larger than that of orbital riveting. It takes 13 rotations of fleurettes to complete one full 360 ° pass with radial riveting, whereas an orbital path only takes one. For this reason, the internal components between the two types of powerheads differ greatly. Orbital heads include three industrial standard bearings held in place by a snap ring. Maintenance includes removing the snap ring, cleaning, greasing and replacing the bearings. This process, on average, takes around a half hour and should be completed every 40 hours of part contact. The bearings are a standard bearing that can be found at any tool supply shop, meaning you are able to replace bearings quickly in an emergency. The total cost to replace all internal components for an orbital head is minimal. Conversely, radial riveting requires more internal components to create the tool path. The range of movement creates friction and heat, causing internal components to break down quicker. It is critical to grease the internal bearing, pre-load spring and thrust cup every 40 machine hours (not contact hours as in orbital riveting) to limit heat. Also, the rubbing of the pre-load spring and thrust cup to create the florets and rotation creates galling and increased wear. As these components break down, required maintenance and machine downtime due to maintenance increases. Due to the complexity of the components, the cost of replacing internal components of a radial head is three to four times that of orbital riveting.

Making the choice

When choosing between orbital and radial riveting, total cost of ownership, joint function, size, forming force required, and future machine maintenance costs must be taken into consideration. The financial obligations and time required for maintenance are not to be taken lightly, as it can greatly affect your throughput. As you approach the initial design phase of a new project, call the experts at Orbitform to discuss your assembly requirements to determine the appropriate riveting process. Our Applications Engineers and Lab Technicians stand ready to work with you to find the best solution for your assembly.

 

Orbitize Your Inbox

Get real-time insight from Orbitform experts delivered to your inbox. Gear up for the latest and greatest on forming, fastening, automation, and overall assembly innovation.

Does your conveyor application require part orientation, in-line processes, traffic control, or part buffering?

Read More

When working with a new machine, there is nothing more unnerving than premature tool wear. We have a solution!

Read More
Large conveyor supplied from Wardcraft for part handling

Increase ROI when offering customizable products with adjustable assembly equipment

Read More

SERVO-Driven electric forming machines are a clean and more accurate way to assemble parts.

Read More

Roller Forming can be an alternative to crimping when quality issues arise.

Read More

Recently, a customer contacted us after a machine shipped via cargo ship through the Atlantic Ocean was mishandled and left crated for an extensive amount of time.

Read More

Decrease cycle time when using orbital forming by forming more than one rivet at once with our multi-spindle and multi-point options.

Read More

To combat increasing labor shortages Orbitform provides many solutions in the form of automation. Every assembly is unique and we are able to provide a solution that is just as unique...

Read More

Orbitform puts customers first as we strive to set new standards for excellence in Fastening, Forming, and Assembly.

Read More

Comparing these two processes results in the same finished form but very different force requirements to get there.

Read More
Orbitform Hot Upset

The Hot Upset Process uses high heat similar to welding, but the result is quite different.

Read More

With this rise in demand, manufacturers are seeking out solutions to help increase their production volume as quickly as possible.

Read More

Orbitform stands ready to partner with essential manufacturers through assembling products to support pandemic support efforts

Read More

A dome shaped finished form was required and the dimensions were critical to match the manufactured end and remain aesthetically pleasing.

READ MORE

Through tough times, Orbitform continues to support manufacturers worldwide. Even after machine shipment and installation

Read More

Partnering with Orbitform can simplify this process.

Read More

This new Jaw Lowering Safety Device solves the clearance challenges posed by typical impact riveting safety devices by using the already present jaws to check for clearance.

Read More

Leveraging our powerhead as a press, Orbitform completed the bushing flare and flatten in two locations with a multi-tool head.

Read More

Orbitform and a group of investors acquired C & B Machinery, provider of world-class disc grinding and metal removal equipment solutions

Read More

… reached out to Orbitform with a challenge in forming an endoscopic surgical tool.

Read More

Manufacturers looking to bring assembly processes in-house partner with Orbitform to validate their process and receive a custom equipment solution.

Read More

“Preventative Maintenance: Don’t start today by doing yesterday’s work” – Deniece Schofield

READ MORE

Factory Remanufactured Machines provide a "better-than-used" solution held to the same standards as new.

Read More

As manufacturing continues to grow and evolve, so too does the need to automate the assembly process. Orbitform’s goal is to work with manufacturers to determine and supply the precise automation level required for an assembly without overcomplicating a system.

Read More

When changes in production happen, retooling existing equipment is a great option that can make a massive difference in Return-on-Investment.

Read More

Orbitform's Engineers deliver another machine solution for an HVAC company

Read More

When the part design requires unconventional joint locations, it becomes a requirement of the assembly process to find a way to reach the joint .

Read More

Orbitform worked with a Design Engineer on a medical device project. The design called for two rivets to be formed, both of different sizes and requiring different torque specs. Orbitform’s engineers reviewed the design...

Read More

Orbitform is excited to announce the acquisition of Diamond Precision Tool Group.

Read More

Orbitform develops the UVC Decontamination Chamber to decontaminate N95 Masks

Read More

De-riveting is a common technique used to save money and re-work parts. When seeking a solution for de-riveting assemblies, many manufacturers turn to Orbitform.

Read More

With the rising concerns over COVID-19, we are working diligently to take precautions while continuing to deliver safe results. 

Read More

In an effort to increase speed across our operations, Orbitform has standardized on our machine paint colors.

Read More

Can plastic fasteners be cold formed using the orbital process?

Read More

When annual volume requirements are high, this unique machine combines two automation solutions into one piece of equipment.

Read More

Find how Orbitform helped a customer develop a robust forming solution for their landing gear rotors and stators.

Read More

Form rivets close to other part features when normal assembly processes might have clearance issues.

Read More

What preventative maintenance you should do for your Orbitform machines.

Read More

When manufacturers are ready to reshore, Orbitform is a trusted advisor.

Read More

Read More

Ultimately, the shape of the peen tool affects the final form geometry, the forming process, and resulting joint.

Read More

Read More

Get the inside scoop on which spare parts you need to avoid any unnecessary downtime.

Read More

Read More

For manufacturers looking for the most cost-effective solution, our new Digital Stroke Counter ensures accuracy of changeover and results in less scrap parts.

Read More

October is an exciting time at Orbitform as we unveil new products at community events in preparation for The Assembly Show.

Read More

When manufacturers work with a variety of assemblies, it’s important to find cost-effective solutions to positively impact the bottom line.

Read More

Using video chat options to view assembling prototypes in Orbitform's Solutions Lab

Read More

When precision and consistency from part to part are critical, manufacturers can greatly benefit from incorporating a pressure pad on their equipment.

Read More

Orbitform was contacted by a customer with a three-year-old orbital machine. They noticed that their powerhead would drift down when operators walked away.

Read More

Keeping Safety Our Top Priority

Read More

How to Determine the Right Assembly Equipment

Read More

Working With the Food Industry

Read More

Finding You the Best Fit Assembly Process

Read More

Forming Carrier Pins in a Transmission Planetary Carrier Gear

Read More

Providing the Best Fit Quality Solutions

Read More

The Leading Expert in Palletized Conveyors

Read More

A Cost Effective Solution

Read More

Choosing the Right Automation Process

Read More

Determining The Best Process For Your Part

Read More

Adding Value With Trumpf Laser Cutter

Read More

Automotive Applications Assembled 

Read More

Unique and Flexible Riveting Solutions

Read More

Taking Big Steps in the Right Direction

Read More

Expansion of Product Offerings

Read More

Since 1984, Orbitform has been evolving with the best interests of our customers. Here's our story of perpetual growth.

Read More

The Benefits of Orbitally Forming a Flare

Read More

Investing In Continuous Improvement 

Read More

What’s the difference?

Read More

Increasing Quality and Production Rates

Read More

Meeting Your Assembly Requirements

Read More

A Wide Flat Roller Solution

Read More

How We Can Support Your Manufacturing Needs

Read More

Combining Processes and Cutting The Costs

Read More

Eliminating the Cyber Threats

Read More

Safety is The #1 Priority

Read More

Orbitform Engineers Find the Solution

Read More

Articulating Roller Forming Solves Crisis 

Read More

Providing the Highest Quality Products

Read More

Finding The Right Fit

Read More

Process Monitoring and Control

Read More

Our Unbiased Approach

Read More

Why You Should Invest in Spare Parts and Tooling

Read More

Showcasing Our New Products

Read More

Keeping Sprinkler Head Assembly Consistent

Read More

Experience the "Orbitform Way"

Read More

Solutions For Filling The Pipelines

Read More

Students Work Together to Solve Real-World Problems

Read More

Continuous Improvement to the Milford Product Line

Read More

Attending AMC's 1st Annual Graduation Dinner

Read More

Bearing Retention Within a Water Pump

Read More

Hot Upset Process Forms Tungsten Rivets

Read More

High Efficiency Process Created Through Orbital Forming

Read More

The Process of Pushing the Boundaries

Read More

All Your Riveting Equipment Made In House

Read More

The Impact Riveting Assembly Process

Read More

Keeping the Part Safe & Secure

Read More

Using Media for the Right Reasons

Read More

Maintaining a Clean Facility

Read More

A Huge Thank You to All Who Serve Our Country

Read More

President of Orbitform Honored With Award

Read More

Find The Best Fit Machine With the Solutions Lab

Read More

The Breakthrough That Changed Manufacturing

Read More

Preparation for the Assembly Trade Show

Read More

Providing Stability With Roller Forming

Read More

Orbitform Hosts Jackson High School Students

Read More

The Story of an Attic Door

Read More

Gaining Insight About Assembly Applications

Read More

Come Visit The Orbitform Booth!

Read More

Production Work In The Orbitform Lab

Read More

Showcasing Our Products

Read More

Riveting Of A Truck Part

Read More

Keeping the Milford Name Alive

Read More

Everyday Household Items Assembled With Riveting Machines

Read More

Manufacturing Products With the Best Assembly Process

Read More

Rollerforming Assembly For Large Diameter Parts

Read More

Orbitform's New Sales Partnership

Read More

Advantages and Challenges Presented

Read More

Riveting All Types of Kitchen Utensils

Read More

Providing High Quality Solutions for Food Processing Industry

Read More

Orbitform Engineers Take on New Challenges

Read More

How The Assembly Process Came To Be

Read More

Assembling Cooking and Baking Equipment

Read More

Advantages of Orbital Riveting and Forming

Read More

Finding The Best Fit Assembly Process

Read More

An Alternative Permanent Assembly Method

Read More

Keeping Safety a Top Priority

Read More

Students Apply Engineering Knowledge To Competition

Read More

Developing Locking Mechanism for Spinal Support Plate

Read More

What's the Difference?

Read More

Orbitform Engineers Develop New Goose Neck Design

Read More

9th Place Finish at the Michigan State Championship

Read More

Giving Vacuum Power Grips A Smooth Assembly Process

Read More

Orbitform's Unbiased Approach

Read More

Hosting a Fantastic Group of Visitors

Read More

Versatility of Orbitform Machines

Read More

A Fun-Filled Day Of Learning

Read More

Designing a Custom Assembly

Read More

Solutions Lab Develops New Prototype

Read More

Working Together to Develop an Effective Assembly 

Read More

 Using Articulating Rollerforming in Conjunction With Servo Powerhead

Read More

Riveting Machine Rebuild Company Purchased By Orbitform

Read More

Working With A Furniture Mechanism Supplier

Read More

Riveting Machine Parts & Tooling

Read More

A Knowledge-Filled Day For The Kids

Read More

Permanently Assembling Metals Without The Hassle

Read More

Growing Our Business

Read More

Delivering Quality Solutions 

Read More

Assembling All Types Of Medical Devices

Read More

A New Era of Rollerforming

Read More

With Orbitform, You Wont Have to Settle

Read More

Developing An Assembly Process For Coffee Mills

Read More

4 Tips To Keep Your Orbital Assembly Running Smoothly

Read More

Recognition of Orbitform Employee

Read More

Finding The Right Process For You

Read More

Impact Riveting Machines Creating Higher Efficiency

Read More

In Memory of Pat Beach

Read More

Options For Forming

Read More

30 Years of Assembly Experience Working For You!

Read More

Advantages of Permanent Part Assembly

Read More

6 Reasons Why You Should Go Permanent

Read More

Take Advantage of Orbitform's Permanent Assembly Processes

Read More

Smooth Non-Impact Forming Solutions

Read More

Fast and Permanent Assembly Equipment

Read More

3 Different Types of Impact Applications

Read More

Orbitform's Hot New Riveting Process

Read More

Permanent Assembly for Large Cylindrical Parts

Read More

Forming With a Sweeping Line of Pressure

Read More

The Orbital Alternative

Read More

Multi-Point Impact Riveting

Read More

Assembly Automation by Orbitform

Read More

Increase Throughput and Produce Parts Faster

Read More

Smooth, Non-Impact Forming Solutions

Read More

Precision Control in a Clean Environment

Read More

The One-Stop Shop to Fit All Your Needs

Read More

Four Special Points to Consider

Read More

How To Determine the Right Sized Powerhead

Read More